Beyond Borrowing
Many students learn to regroup in subtraction without understanding what the regrouping records. You will learn how students develop multi-digit subtraction strategies and how place-value knowledge connects to the standard algorithm. The shift is from following the regrouping steps to asking, at each place, whether there are enough units to subtract.
- Insight PDF, free The research overview. About 3 pages, with references. (opens in a new tab)
- Newsletter PDF, free Start here 2 pages for teachers and families: one classroom example, the central idea, and things to try. (opens in a new tab)
- Companion PDF, free For coaches and study groups: questions to ask, student work to analyze, and teacher moves to plan for. (opens in a new tab)
Questions for your classroom
- A student subtracts 43 − 27 accurately but cannot explain what changed during regrouping. What might you ask?
- A student says 52 becomes smaller when it is regrouped as 4 tens and 12 ones. How would you respond?
- How can teachers connect the standard algorithm to the base-ten units being composed and decomposed?
Read the Insight
Beyond Borrowing: Understanding the Structure of Subtraction
How place-value units are composed and decomposed in multi-digit subtraction
Introduction
Multi-digit subtraction is often taught through a sequence of steps commonly described as “borrowing.” Students may learn to cross out digits, rewrite numbers, and follow the standard algorithm without understanding the place-value relationships those procedures represent.
Research on children’s mathematical thinking has examined how students develop multi-digit subtraction strategies, how they understand tens and ones, and why certain errors occur when regrouping. This research offers important insights into the relationship between place-value knowledge, mathematical representations, and written procedures.
This DMT Insight reviews research on the development of multi-digit subtraction strategies, the mathematical structure underlying regrouping, and the connections between conceptual understanding and procedural fluency.
Subtraction and Place-Value Relationships
Subtraction can represent removing a quantity, determining a difference, or finding an unknown quantity. Selter et al. (2012) examine taking away and determining the difference as two important models of subtraction. These relationships influence students' strategies, but multi-digit subtraction also requires understanding how place-value units represent quantities. DMT Insight 45 examines subtraction situations and their relationships in greater detail. Here, the emphasis is on how students develop place-value understanding and connect that knowledge to subtraction procedures.
Place-Value Knowledge and Multi-Digit Subtraction
Fuson (1992) reviewed research on whole-number addition and subtraction and described how children’s multi-digit calculation depends on understanding numbers as composed of units of different sizes. A written numeral such as 43 records four units of ten and three units of one. Children who treat digits as independent single-digit numbers can follow steps that look correct while losing track of the quantities those digits represent. Fuson and colleagues (1997) examined how children’s conceptual structures for multi-digit numbers relate to their addition and subtraction methods. Their work shows the importance of understanding tens and ones as units rather than treating written numerals as independent digits. This distinction becomes especially important when a subtraction problem requires regrouping. A quantity such as 43 can be represented as four tens and three ones or three tens and thirteen ones. The representation changes, but the quantity stays the same.
43 = 4 tens + 3 ones
43 = 3 tens + 13 ones
Teachers’ understanding of this structure shapes how they explain the algorithm. Ma (1999) found that many U.S. teachers described regrouping as “borrowing,” while many Chinese teachers explained it as decomposing a higher-value unit and connected it to composing units in addition. DMTI’s materials describe regrouping in the same terms, as decomposing one unit into ten units of the next smaller place (Brendefur et al., 2021). That language is an instructional framework consistent with this research, not a finding the studies establish.
Figure 1. In 43 − 29, one ten is decomposed into ten ones. The quantity remains 43, and the written procedure records the decomposition.
Regrouping decomposes one unit into ten units of the next smaller place. The representation changes. The quantity does not.
Research on Children’s Multi-Digit Subtraction Strategies
Children use a range of strategies when solving subtraction problems, including direct modeling, counting back, counting up, and reasoning from known number relationships. Research on children’s mathematical thinking shows that these strategies vary with the problem, the numbers, and children’s developing knowledge (Carpenter et al., 1999). Siegler (1996) describes how children use multiple strategies and how their strategy choices change as their knowledge develops.
Carpenter et al. (1998) followed 82 children from first through third grade and interviewed them repeatedly about multi-digit addition and subtraction. About 90 percent of the children used invented strategies at some point. Children who used invented strategies before learning standard algorithms showed stronger knowledge of base-ten number concepts and were more successful at extending their knowledge to new situations than children who learned the algorithms first. Because the children were observed rather than assigned to different instruction, the study describes an association between strategies and understanding, not the effect of a particular teaching sequence. Fuson et al. (1997) connected children’s methods to their conceptual structures for two-digit numbers. Children who think of a number as a sequence of tens and ones tend to count on or back by tens, while children who think of separate tens and ones tend to operate on each place. Beishuizen (1993) found that Dutch second graders who split both numbers into tens and ones made more errors on subtraction problems that required regrouping than students who kept the first number whole and subtracted tens and the n ones. For 43 − 29, splitting produces 40 − 20 and 3 − 9, and the second step cannot be completed without regrouping. Jumping from the first number, 43 − 20 = 23 and 23 − 9 = 14, avoids that step.
Understanding Regrouping and Written Algorithms
The standard algorithm records regrouping compactly. At each place, it answers the same question: Are there enough units in this place to subtract? If not, one unit of the next greater place is decomposed into ten units of this place. In 402 − 178, there are not enough ones, and the tens place contains no tens to decompose. One hundred is decomposed into ten tens, and one of those tens is decomposed into ten ones:
402 = 4 hundreds + 0 tens + 2 ones
402 = 3 hundreds + 10 tens + 2 ones
402 = 3 hundreds + 9 tens + 12 ones
The 3 written above the 4 records three remaining hundreds, the 9 above the 0 records nine tens, and the 12 records twelve ones. Each mark corresponds to an equivalent representation of 402. Fuson (1992) describes written multi-digit methods as records of these unit exchanges. When students understand the exchanges, the marks have meaning. When they do not, the notation becomes a set of rules to remember, and problems with zeros in the minuend are a common place for errors (Brown & VanLehn, 1982).
What Research Reveals About Subtraction Errors
Brown and VanLehn (1982) examined systematic errors in subtraction procedures and described how students may construct incorrect rules when they encounter steps they do not know how to complete. Many of the errors they analyzed involve borrowing, particularly from a zero. Such errors can reveal students' procedures, but a single incorrect answer is not enough to show how a student understands the mathematics.
For example, a student who writes 43 − 29 = 26 may be subtracting the smaller digit from the larger digit in each column (9 − 3 = 6 and 4 − 2 = 2). The same answer could come from a one-time mistake or from a rule the student applies consistently. Distinguishing a mistake from a misconception requires more evidence than one response, such as the student’s explanation or work on other problems that require regrouping.
Hiebert and Wearne (1986) studied students’ knowledge of decimal numbers and found that many students learned rules for manipulating written symbols without connecting them to the quantities the symbols represent. Their study concerns decimals, but it describes the same broader pattern: procedures carried out without reference to units are more likely to break down in unfamiliar cases.
Representations, Mathematical Structure, and Procedural Understanding
Research on mathematical representations emphasizes that models can help students organize quantities and relationships. In multi-digit subtraction, base-ten representations can make the composition and decomposition of units visible, while number lines can represent differences and relationships among quantities. The instructional significance lies in how students use and connect these representations to their strategies and written procedures.
Realistic Mathematics Education describes models that begin as situation models and become models for mathematical reasoning (Gravemeijer, 1994). Treffers (1991) described a primary mathematics program in which written procedures develop gradually from students’ informal methods. Neither framework requires students to complete a fixed sequence from concrete materials to pictures to symbols. Representations and written procedures can develop together as students connect them.
Implications of the Research
Research on multi-digit subtraction suggests that students’ understanding of place-value units is closely connected to the strategies and procedures they use. Studies of children’s invented strategies, conceptual structures, and systematic errors show why teachers need to understand the mathematics students represent.
This research also supports connecting mathematical representations, student reasoning, and written procedures. Yackel and Cobb (1996) describe how classroom norms for what counts as an acceptable mathematical explanation develop as students explain and compare their methods. Conceptual understanding and procedural fluency should develop together, with opportunities for students to examine relationships and practice increasingly efficient methods.
Understanding place-value units and practicing efficient procedures develop together. Neither has to wait for the other.
Conclusion
Research on multi-digit subtraction shows the importance of students’ understanding of place-value units and the relationships represented by their strategies and procedures.
Fuson and colleagues examined how children’s understanding of multi-digit numbers influences their calculation methods. Carpenter and colleagues documented the development of children’s invented strategies, while Brown and VanLehn identified systematic errors that can occur when students apply written procedures without understanding particular steps.
Together, these studies help explain why regrouping should be understood as composing and decomposing equivalent quantities rather than simply following a sequence of written steps.
The goal is for students to understand the mathematical relationships represented by subtraction procedures and develop accurate, efficient methods they can use across different situations.
References
Beishuizen, M. (1993). Mental strategies and materials or models for addition and subtraction up to 100 in Dutch second grades. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 24(4), 294-323.
Brendefur, J. L., Strother, S., Ismail, J., & Krone, K. (2021). Developing mathematical thinking for number and early algebra workbook: Number. Developing Mathematical Thinking Institute.
Brown, J. S., & VanLehn, K. (1982). Towards a generative theory of “bugs.” In T. P. Carpenter, J. M. Moser, & T. A. Romberg (Eds.), Addition and subtraction: A cognitive perspective (pp. 117-135). Lawrence Erlbaum.
Carpenter, T. P., Fennema, E., Franke, M. L., Levi, L., & Empson, S. B. (1999). Children’s mathematics: Cognitively guided instruction. Heinemann.
Carpenter, T. P., Franke, M. L., Jacobs, V. R., Fennema, E., & Empson, S. B. (1998). A longitudinal study of invention and understanding in children’s multidigit addition and subtraction. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 29(1), 3-20.
Fuson, K. C. (1992). Research on whole number addition and subtraction. In D. A. Grouws (Ed.), Handbook of research on mathematics teaching and learning (pp. 243-275). Macmillan.
Fuson, K. C., Wearne, D., Hiebert, J. C., Murray, H. G., Human, P. G., Olivier, A. I., Carpenter, T. P., & Fennema, E. (1997). Children’s conceptual structures for multidigit numbers and methods of multidigit addition and subtraction. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 28(2), 130-162.
Gravemeijer, K. (1994). Developing realistic mathematics education. Freudenthal Institute.
Hiebert, J., & Wearne, D. (1986). Procedures over concepts: The acquisition of decimal number knowledge. In J. Hiebert (Ed.), Conceptual and procedural knowledge: The case of mathematics (pp. 199-223). Lawrence Erlbaum.
Ma, L. (1999). Knowing and teaching elementary mathematics: Teachers’ understanding of fundamental mathematics in China and the United States. Lawrence Erlbaum.
Selter, C., Prediger, S., Nührenbörger, M., & Hußmann, S. (2012). Taking away and determining the difference, a longitudinal perspective on two models of subtraction and the inverse relation to addition. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 79(3), 389-408. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10649-011-9305-6
Siegler, R. S. (1996). Emerging minds: The process of change in children’s thinking. Oxford University Press.
Treffers, A. (1991). Didactical background of a mathematics program for primary education. In L. Streefland (Ed.), Realistic mathematics education in primary school (pp. 21-56). Freudenthal Institute.
Yackel, E., & Cobb, P. (1996). Sociomathematical norms, argumentation, and autonomy in mathematics. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 27(4), 458-477.
Next in this study path
More in Addition & Subtraction
Ready to teach this?
Math Success has the classroom materials behind this Insight.
Core materials
- Grade 2 · Unit 5 · Number Operations: Join and Separate
- Grade 3 · Unit 1 · Place Value: Addition & Subtraction
- Grade 4 · Unit 1 · Number Sense & Place Value
Intervention materials
- Whole Numbers · Addition / Subtraction, grades K-2
- Fact Fluency · Addition / Subtraction, grades K-2
- Whole Numbers · Addition / Subtraction, grades 3-5
- Fact Fluency · Addition / Subtraction, grades 3-5
Games
- Fluency Dash
- Math Fluency with Sports: Addition & Subtraction
- Dino Dice
PD video
- Addition and Subtraction Fluency: Summary
- Subtraction: Regrouping Across Zero
- Subtraction: Regrouping Across Zero Part 2
The Insights explain the mathematics. Math Success gives you the materials to teach it.
One subscription opens everything, for kindergarten through grade 8. You can start today.
Schools can enroll a whole building for $2,000 a year. See school plans
$21 a month per educator
- All core materials
- All intervention materials
- Diagnostics
- Games
- Prep materials: online video professional development
Keep developing mathematical thinkers.