Scaling and Comparing
The move from additive to multiplicative reasoning is one of the most important and protracted transitions in the curriculum. You will learn how scaling, multiplicative comparison, composite units, rate reasoning, and equivalent ratios develop across multiplication, division, and patterns. The shift is from asking “how many more” to asking “how many times as much.”
- Insight PDF, free The research overview. About 3 pages, with references. (opens in a new tab)
- Newsletter PDF, free Start here 2 pages for teachers and families: one classroom example, the central idea, and things to try. (opens in a new tab)
- Companion PDF, free For coaches and study groups: questions to ask, student work to analyze, and teacher moves to plan for. (opens in a new tab)
Questions for your classroom
- A student can find “how much more” one quantity is than another but struggles with “how many times as much.” What relationship has changed?
- One student says a 6-foot tree is 3 feet taller than a 3-foot tree. Another says it is twice as tall. What does each comparison describe?
- In your word problems, how often do students meet “how many times as much” compared with “how many more”?
Read the Insight
Scaling & Comparing: From Additive to Multiplicative Reasoning
Introduction: A Gateway to Proportional Reasoning and a Genuine Conceptual Challenge
Few transitions in the Grades 3 to 8 curriculum carry as much long-term weight, or cause as much difficulty, as the move from additive to multiplicative reasoning. Scaling and comparing involve students reasoning about how two quantities change together, how many times as much one is as another, and what happens to a shape, a recipe, or a rate when both quantities grow or shrink by the same factor. It is also where many students stall, because the additive strategies they have used for years begin to fail. The reasoning matters beyond the topic itself. In a cohort of British children followed over five years, mathematical reasoning, including multiplicative and proportional reasoning, predicted later mathematics achievement more strongly than arithmetic skill did, with age, general ability, and working memory controlled (Nunes et al., 2012). Reviews describe the development as one of the most protracted and important in school mathematics (Lamon, 2007; Tourniaire & Pulos, 1985).
Scaling and comparing involve several related mathematical ideas that students gradually coordinate: scaling, multiplicative comparison, composite units, rate reasoning, and equivalent ratios (Lamon, 2007; Lobato & Ellis, 2010; Vergnaud, 1988). These ideas do not form a separate DMTI Math Learning Profile (MLP). Instead, they develop across the Multiplication & Division and Patterns & Equality MLPs. Multiplication & Division develops the multiplicative structures, units, factors, and scaling relationships behind this reasoning. Patterns & Equality extends that reasoning as students attend to equivalent relationships and what remains invariant as quantities change. From a cognitive perspective, learning to reason multiplicatively requires a reorganization of what comparison means: students must move from asking how many more to asking how many times as much, and treat the factor that links two quantities as the object of reasoning rather than the difference between them (Thompson & Saldanha, 2003). Understanding both of these demands, the mathematical structure and the cognitive reorganization, is essential for learning and teaching this material well. Simon (2006) termed these reorganizations key developmental understandings: conceptual advances that make later concepts and procedures learnable rather than merely memorable.
Scaling and comparing develop alongside related topics, and this insight stays within its own scope. Base-ten units and the size of a number belong to Place Value. Partitioning a unit of 1 and naming the resulting parts belongs to Fraction Concepts. Building a quantity as a length and iterating a unit along it belongs to Building the Number Line. What belongs here is the factor that relates two quantities and the reasoning that keeps both quantities scaling together. The developmental ideas examined here are held primarily within Multiplication & Division and Patterns & Equality rather than assessed as a separate profile.
Scaling and comparing require a shift in what comparison means, from how many more to how many times as much. The factor, rather than the difference, becomes the relationship students reason about.
The Structure of Scaling and Comparing
A central insight from decades of research is that a multiplicative situation can be read in several related ways. Building on Vergnaud’s (1988) analysis of multiplicative structures, researchers describe scaling and comparing as comprising several interrelated ideas: scaling (growing or shrinking a quantity by a factor while its structure stays the same), multiplicative comparison (how many times as much one quantity is as another), composite units (treating a ratio such as 3 cups to 2 batches as a single unit that can be iterated and partitioned), rate (a relationship between two different units, such as dollars per pound), and equivalent ratios (two ratios related by the same factor). Competent reasoning requires students to recognize these meanings, distinguish among them, and move flexibly among them (Lamon, 2007; Lobato & Ellis, 2010).
Instruction has traditionally overemphasized procedures, especially cross-multiplication, at the expense of the underlying reasoning (Lamon, 2007). While a procedure provides a reliable answer, it is a limited foundation. It does not explain why two ratios are equivalent; it hides the factor that links the quantities, and it gives students no way to judge whether an answer is reasonable. Theoretical work identifies the composite unit and the multiplicative comparison as ideas that support equivalence and proportional reasoning (Lobato & Ellis, 2010; Thompson & Saldanha, 2003). A coherent curriculum develops these ideas together, with particular attention to the factor that relates two quantities and the relationships that remain invariant as quantities change.
Scaling and comparing bring together several related ideas: scaling, multiplicative comparison, composite units, rate reasoning, and equivalent ratios. These ideas connect multiplicative reasoning with reasoning about patterns, equality, and equivalent relationships.
The Additive Bias: Reorganizing Comparison
Perhaps the single most documented obstacle in this domain is the tendency to treat multiplicative situations additively (Tourniaire & Pulos, 1985; Van Dooren et al., 2005). Because students spend their early years reasoning about how many more and how many fewer, they build strong, well-practiced intuitions: comparison means finding a difference, and a quantity grows by adding to it. These intuitions succeed for years, and they are often the correct reading. They fail when the situation is multiplicative, and the additive habit continues. The student’s additive reasoning is not unreasonable. It is a conception that worked in earlier situations and is now being used where the relationship is multiplicative.
Every upper-elementary teacher recognizes the consequences. When asked to enlarge a 4-by-6 rectangle so its width becomes 6, students add 2 to the height and report 8, keeping the difference while changing the shape. Adding 2 preserves the difference; scaling by 1.5 preserves the multiplicative relationship. When asked to double a recipe that calls for 3 cups of flour for 2 batches, they add the same amount to each and change the recipe. They read a ratio of 3 to 4 as a 3 and a 4, two separate numbers, and extend a proportion by adding to each. Across 325 students in Grades 3 to 6, additive answers dominated in Grade 3 and proportional answers by Grade 6, and nearly half of the older students made both errors, applying proportional reasoning to additive situations as readily as the reverse. Only about five percent solved all four item types correctly (Van Dooren et al., 2010). Over-application persists across ages and problem types (Van Dooren et al., 2005). The goal of assessment and instruction together is not to add a rule but to help students reorganize comparison so that the factor linking two quantities becomes what they track. Assessment should therefore reveal whether a student is tracking the difference between quantities or the factor that relates them.
The additive bias, reading a multiplicative situation as a difference to be added, is the central obstacle in scaling and comparing; the goal of assessment and instruction together is not more rules but a reorganization of comparison so that the multiplicative factor becomes the object of reasoning.
CLASSROOM SNAPSHOT
Teacher: “This recipe uses 3 cups of flour for 2 batches. What would we need for 4 batches?”
Student A: “Add 2 cups and 2 batches. So 5 cups for 4 batches.”
Student B: “Double both numbers. 6 cups for 4 batches.”
Teacher: “Why?”
Student B: “Because it still has to taste the same.”
Both students can compute; they differ in whether they track the factor that relates the quantities or the difference between them, which is the additive bias.
Scaling and the Number Line: From Iteration to Proportion
The number line is one model that can make this development visible. On a single line, scaling by a whole number means repeating equal jumps: three jumps of four reach twelve. Locating a fraction is scaling by a factor below one: one-half of the distance from zero to two lands at one. The same line that shows where 12 is relative to 4 also shows where one-half of 2 is, which connects multiplicative comparison with whole numbers to scaling by fractions. The number line makes the multiplicative relationship visible and connects it to symbolic notation. Here the number line is a representation used to expose the relationship. How students build the number line itself belongs to Building the Number Line.
The evidence for the number line is consistent rather than decisive. A meta-analysis of 263 effect sizes from 10,576 students aged 4 to 14 found a moderate association between number-line estimation and broader mathematical competence, stronger for fraction number lines than for whole-number lines (Schneider et al., 2018). Magnitude knowledge is also associated with arithmetic learning in the early grades (Booth & Siegler, 2008). The double number line extends the same idea to two quantities at once. Developed within Realistic Mathematics Education, it shows two measures scaling together along parallel lines, and Freudenthal (1973) and Gravemeijer (1999) described how such a model begins as a model of a specific situation and becomes a model for proportional reasoning in general. That account is a design rationale rather than a demonstration: no controlled study yet isolates the effect of a double number line or a ratio table on student proportional reasoning. Used as a scaling model rather than a counting strip, the number line lets students coordinate two quantities, place a value by reasoning about its magnitude, and apply the same scaling to ratio, proportion, and slope (Lesh et al., 1987).
Used as a scaling model rather than a counting strip, the number line connects whole-number iteration to fraction and proportional reasoning within one representation, and number-line estimation is consistently associated with broader mathematical competence.
Developmental Foundations: Composite Units and Coordinating Quantities
The number line makes a multiplicative relationship visible, and students use it meaningfully when they have built the understandings behind it, above all the composite unit. Long before students meet formal ratio notation, they have intuitive resources for multiplicative reasoning, reasoning about equal groups, fair shares, and simple scaling in familiar contexts, and these informal strategies form a productive foundation (Carpenter et al., 1996). Noelting (1980), analyzing children comparing orange-juice mixtures, described a sequence in which students first compare within a single quantity and only later coordinate two quantities at once. The sequence is not a ladder every student climbs on schedule. Among early adolescents given rate problems, strategy varied with the numbers and the context rather than with age, and the two age groups tested differed little (Karplus et al., 1983). What develops is the range of situations in which a student can coordinate two quantities, not a fixed order of strategies.
Two developmental ideas are central. The first is the composite unit. A ratio such as 3 cups for 2 batches can be treated as one composite unit. Students can iterate that unit to generate 6 cups for 4 batches or partition it to generate smaller equivalent ratios (Lamon, 2007; Lobato & Ellis, 2010). The second is unitizing: understanding what counts as “one” and recognizing that the unit can be redefined, that a group of objects, or a pair of quantities, can itself be treated as a single unit. The unit changes from one quantity to a relationship between two quantities. Coordinating the composite unit is what allows a student to generate and compare equivalent ratios rather than track four separate numbers. Realistic Mathematics Education emphasizes building these ideas from meaningful contexts of sharing, mixing, and measurement before formalizing them (Freudenthal, 1973; Gravemeijer, 1999). The instructional implication is that multiplicative reasoning should be built from students’ own coordinating activity rather than introduced as ready-made symbolic rules.
This is where Scaling & Comparing connects directly to the Multiplication & Division MLP. Students must be able to unitize, compose groups, iterate a unit, and reason about a multiplicative factor before those same actions can be coordinated across two quantities.
Scaling and comparing should be built from students’ own coordinating activity, forming a ratio as one composite unit, then iterating and partitioning it, rather than introduced as ready-made procedures.
Preserving a Relationship: The Connection to Patterns & Equality
Scaling also requires students to attend to what changes and what remains the same. In a ratio table, the quantities change while the multiplicative relationship remains invariant. In equivalent ratios such as 2:3, 4:6, and 6:9, the numbers are different, but the relationship is preserved. This connects Scaling & Comparing to the Patterns & Equality MLP: students reason about equivalence, identify a relationship across changing quantities, and generalize the structure that remains the same.
The important question is not simply, “What comes next?” It is, “What relationship is being preserved?”
Cognitive Psychology Foundations: Models, Procedures, and Transfer
Three findings from cognitive psychology support this progression. First, models make relationships visible. A multiplicative comparison is demanding because it asks a student to coordinate two quantities and a factor at once, and working memory is limited (Sweller, 1988). A double number line or a ratio table plausibly shifts some of that coordination onto an external structure. However, that extends the theory to these models rather than finding something about them.
Second, conceptual and procedural knowledge develop together. When students learn a procedure such as cross multiplication apart from the multiplicative relationship, they have no way to judge whether an answer is reasonable (Hiebert & Carpenter, 1992). The third is that transfer comes through recognizing structure: students apply what they have learned to new situations when they have grasped the underlying structure rather than the surface features of the problems they first met (Bransford et al., 2000). The instructional implication is to connect models and notation so the same multiplicative relationship remains visible as the representation becomes more formal.
Conceptual and procedural knowledge develop together. Connect models and notation so the same multiplicative relationship remains visible as the representation becomes more formal.
Where Scaling & Comparing Lives in the DMTI Math Learning Profiles
The research reviewed here leads to a practical question: if reasoning multiplicatively is this consequential and this fragile, where does a teacher see it? Scaling and comparing are not a separate MLP. They form a developmental thread that becomes visible across the Multiplication & Division and Patterns & Equality MLPs. Multiplication & Division builds the multiplicative structure and the factor. Scaling and comparing coordinate two quantities and preserve the multiplicative relationship. Patterns & Equality recognizes, represents, and generalizes what remains invariant. The same student reasoning can inform more than one profile, so this reasoning does not need a profile of its own.
Multiplication & Division. This MLP develops the multiplicative structure behind scaling and comparing: multiplicative thinking, the factor, composite units and unitizing, iteration and partitioning, scaling a quantity, and multiplicative comparison. A student who grows or shrinks a quantity by a factor while its structure stays the same, so that a figure keeps its shape and a recipe keeps its taste, is scaling (Lobato & Ellis, 2010). A student who asks how many times as much one quantity is as another, and tracks that factor rather than the difference, is comparing multiplicatively (Thompson & Saldanha, 2003). A student who treats 3 cups to 2 batches as one unit that can be iterated and partitioned is reasoning with a composite unit (Lamon, 2007; Lobato & Ellis, 2010). Ask a student to make a bar model three times as long and then half as long, or to say both how many times as long and how many more, and the response shows whether the student is reasoning with a factor or a difference.
Patterns & Equality. This MLP extends that reasoning to relationships between quantities: equivalence, invariant relationships, generating equivalent relationships, and recognizing and generalizing a multiplicative pattern. A student who builds 6 cups for 4 batches and 9 cups for 6 batches from 3 cups for 2 batches is generating equivalent relationships. A student who can say what changed and what remained the same across those ratios has identified the invariant relationship. A student who can state the relationship for any number of batches has generalized it. Both profiles. Rate reasoning draws on both. A student coordinates two different units, such as dollars per pound, and treats the rate as one relationship rather than two loose numbers (Lamon, 2007). That coordination depends on the multiplicative structure developed in Multiplication & Division, and using the rate across changing quantities is the reasoning developed in Patterns & Equality. Ask what one pound costs when four pounds cost twenty dollars, and listen for whether the student builds down to one or reaches for cross multiplication.
Across Grades 3 to 6, the reasoning runs from iterating a unit and comparing with whole numbers, through scaling by a unit fraction and iterating a ratio on a ratio table, to scaling continuous quantities and expressing comparisons as a rate or a percent. One further understanding is drawn from another MLP: fraction magnitude, the sense that a factor can be greater than, equal to, or less than one, which is developed in Fraction Concepts (Booth & Siegler, 2008). Assessment in either profile is most informative when it probes the reasoning in more than one representation, ratio table, double number line, and drawings of figures that grow and shrink, and surfaces the additive bias directly. A student who adds where the situation asks them to scale has revealed a specific, addressable misconception rather than a wrong answer.
Scaling and comparing are not a separate MLP. They form a developmental thread that becomes visible across the Multiplication & Division and Patterns & Equality MLPs. The throughline: identify the factor → coordinate the quantities → preserve the relationship → use the relationship to reason.
Conclusion: A Reorganization from Additive to Multiplicative Reasoning
Scaling and comparing occupy a pivotal place in the Grades 3-8 curriculum because they demand something new: reorganizing comparison from finding a difference to relating two quantities. From a mathematics perspective, teaching it well means developing scaling, multiplicative comparison, composite units, rate reasoning, and equivalent ratios together, with particular attention to the factor that links two quantities. From a cognitive perspective, this means helping students overcome additive bias and coordinate two quantities at once, so conceptual understanding of the multiplicative relationship can anchor and give meaning to procedures.
Multiplicative and proportional reasoning underlies much of the mathematics that follows, so sustained attention to it in the elementary and middle grades matters. When students ask how many times as much rather than how many more, and treat that factor as the thing to find and operate on, they gain not only competence with ratios and proportions but a foundation for fractions, percent, similarity, slope, and the algebra ahead.
For DMTI, this reasoning does not need a separate MLP. It is better understood as a thread connecting Multiplication & Division with Patterns & Equality: students build multiplicative relationships, preserve those relationships as quantities change, and eventually generalize the structure.
Scaling and comparing mark an important shift from additive to multiplicative reasoning. Students move from tracking a difference to coordinating quantities through a factor, a structure that continues into ratio, percent, similarity, slope, and algebra.
References
Booth, J. L., & Siegler, R. S. (2008). Numerical magnitude representations influence arithmetic learning. Child Development, 79(4), 1016-1031. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8624.2008.01173.x
Bransford, J. D., Brown, A. L., & Cocking, R. R. (Eds.). (2000). How people learn: Brain, mind, experience, and school (Expanded ed.). National Academy Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/9853
Carpenter, T. P., Fennema, E., & Franke, M. L. (1996). Cognitively guided instruction: A knowledge base for reform in primary mathematics instruction. The Elementary School Journal, 97(1), 3-20. https://doi.org/10.1086/461846
Freudenthal, H. (1973). Mathematics as an educational task. D. Reidel.
Gravemeijer, K. (1999). How emergent models may foster the constitution of formal mathematics. Mathematical Thinking and Learning, 1(2), 155-177. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327833mtl0102_4
Hiebert, J., & Carpenter, T. P. (1992). Learning and teaching with understanding. In D. A. Grouws (Ed.), Handbook of research on mathematics teaching and learning (pp. 65-97). Macmillan.
Karplus, R., Pulos, S., & Stage, E. K. (1983). Early adolescents’ proportional reasoning on “rate” problems. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 14(3), 219-233. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00410539
Lamon, S. J. (2007). Rational numbers and proportional reasoning: Toward a theoretical framework for research. In F. K. Lester Jr. (Ed.), Second handbook of research on mathematics teaching and learning (pp. 629-667). Information Age Publishing.
Lesh, R., Post, T., & Behr, M. (1987). Representations and translations among representations in mathematics learning and problem solving. In C. Janvier (Ed.), Problems of representation in the teaching and learning of mathematics (pp. 33-40). Lawrence Erlbaum.
Lobato, J., & Ellis, A. B. (2010). Developing essential understanding of ratios, proportions, and proportional reasoning for teaching mathematics: Grades 6-8 (R. M. Zbiek, Ed.). National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
Noelting, G. (1980). The development of proportional reasoning and the ratio concept. Part I: Differentiation of stages. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 11(2), 217-253. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00304357
Nunes, T., Bryant, P., Barros, R., & Sylva, K. (2012). The relative importance of two different mathematical abilities to mathematical achievement. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 82(1), 136-156. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8279.2011.02033.x
Schneider, M., Merz, S., Stricker, J., De Smedt, B., Torbeyns, J., Verschaffel, L., & Luwel, K. (2018). Associations of number line estimation with mathematical competence: A meta-analysis. Child Development, 89(5), 1467-1484. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.13068
Simon, M. A. (2006). Key developmental understandings in mathematics: A direction for investigating and establishing learning goals. Mathematical Thinking and Learning, 8(4), 359-371. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327833mtl0804_1
Sweller, J. (1988). Cognitive load during problem solving: Effects on learning. Cognitive Science, 12(2), 257-285. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15516709cog1202_4
Thompson, P. W., & Saldanha, L. A. (2003). Fractions and multiplicative reasoning. In J. Kilpatrick, W. G. Martin, & D. Schifter (Eds.), A research companion to Principles and Standards for School Mathematics (pp. 95-113). National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
Tourniaire, F., & Pulos, S. (1985). Proportional reasoning: A review of the literature. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 16(2), 181-204. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02400937
Van Dooren, W., De Bock, D., Hessels, A., Janssens, D., & Verschaffel, L. (2005). Not everything is proportional: Effects of age and problem type on propensities for overgeneralization. Cognition and Instruction, 23(1), 57-86. https://doi.org/10.1207/s1532690xci2301_3
Van Dooren, W., De Bock, D., & Verschaffel, L. (2010). From addition to multiplication… and back: The development of students’ additive and multiplicative reasoning skills. Cognition and Instruction, 28(3), 360-381. https://doi.org/10.1080/07370008.2010.488306
Vergnaud, G. (1988). Multiplicative structures. In J. Hiebert & M. Behr (Eds.), Number concepts and operations in the middle grades (pp. 141-161). Lawrence Erlbaum.
More in Ratio & Proportional Reasoning
Ready to teach this?
Math Success has the classroom materials behind this Insight.
Core materials
- Grade 3 · Unit 5 · Multiplication, Division & Area: Part 1
- Grade 4 · Unit 2 · Multiplication, Division, Factors, & Multiples
- Grade 6 · Unit 1 · Proportional Reasoning
- Grade 7 · Unit 1 · Proportional Reasoning
Intervention materials
- Equality, Expressions & Scaling · Scaling, grades 3-5
- Scaling, grades 6-8
PD video
- Ratio and Proportion: Using Context, Ratio Tables, and Models
- Measurement: Conversions Using the Ratio Table
The Insights explain the mathematics. Math Success gives you the materials to teach it.
One subscription opens everything, for kindergarten through grade 8. You can start today.
Schools can enroll a whole building for $2,000 a year. See school plans
$21 a month per educator
- All core materials
- All intervention materials
- Diagnostics
- Games
- Prep materials: online video professional development
Keep developing mathematical thinkers.