The Learning Trifecta
A lesson can run smoothly, with correct answers all around, and still not lead to learning that lasts. You will learn how productive struggle, restraint with hints, and mixed practice strengthen retention and transfer, even when performance during the lesson dips. The shift is from judging a lesson by how well it went to judging it by what students can do later.
- Insight PDF, free The research overview. About 3 pages, with references. (opens in a new tab)
- Newsletter PDF, free Start here 2 pages for teachers and families: one classroom example, the central idea, and things to try. (opens in a new tab)
- Companion PDF, free For coaches and study groups: questions to ask, student work to analyze, and teacher moves to plan for. (opens in a new tab)
Questions for your classroom
- Students answer correctly during a lesson. What evidence would show whether they can use the mathematics later?
- When should teachers provide an explanation, and when should students have time to work through a mathematical relationship?
- A student asks for a hint after one minute. When would waiting help more than helping right away?
Read the Insight
The Learning Trifecta
Struggle, Restraint With Hints, and Mixed Practice
Introduction
A lesson can look successful because students are getting answers right. That does not necessarily tell us what they will be able to do tomorrow, next month, or when the problem looks different.
Three instructional practices help expose that difference: productive struggle, restraint with hints, and mixed practice. Each asks students to make more of the mathematical decisions themselves. That can make performance look worse in the moment. However, the additional thinking can strengthen what students retain and what they can use later (Bjork & Bjork, 2011).
The goal is not difficulty for its own sake. The goal is to leave enough of the mathematics with the student that the student has to reason.
Do not confuse immediate performance with learning that lasts.
Productive Struggle: Give Students Something to Reason From
Productive struggle does not mean leaving students confused or withholding instruction. It means giving students time to make sense of a mathematical relationship before the teacher resolves it for them.
Students might draw a model, decompose a quantity, try a relationship, compare two representations, or test an idea. Their first attempt does not have to be correct to be useful. It gives the subsequent instruction something to connect to.
In one program of studies, seventh-grade students worked on complex problems before the teacher taught the method. They generated a range of representations and methods and did not reach a correct solution. On the posttest, they outperformed students who had been taught the method first (Kapur & Bielaczyc, 2012). Research on mathematics teaching has linked two features of instruction to conceptual understanding: explicit attention to the connections among ideas, and time for students to struggle with important mathematics (Hiebert & Grouws, 2007).
In practice
Give students a problem before demonstrating the method.
Ask students to represent the quantities and relationships.
Ask what they tried and why.
Compare different approaches.
Formalize the mathematics after students have something to formalize.
Productive struggle asks the student to generate and test an idea before the teacher resolves it.
Restraint With Hints: Do Not Remove the Decision
A hint is not neutral. Every hint gives the student information and may remove a decision the student otherwise would have had to make. Enough hints can turn a problem about mathematical relationships into a procedure the student follows.
The issue is not whether the teacher helps. The issue is what the help does. A hint may tell the student what operation to use, which representation to draw, or what step comes next. A guiding question keeps the mathematical decision with the student:
What have you tried?
What quantities do you know?
What are you trying to find?
Can you represent the relationship?
Where did your reasoning stop working?
A stream of directions can shift the student’s attention from reasoning about the problem to remembering and carrying out the teacher’s steps. The student may complete the problem without having made the mathematical decisions that produced the solution.
Attempting a problem before receiving the solution can make the subsequent explanation more useful because the student has already generated, tested, and evaluated an idea. In two randomized studies, students who worked on problems before instruction showed greater conceptual understanding and transfer than students who were taught first, with no loss of procedural knowledge (Kapur, 2014). Laboratory studies of memory show a related effect: people retain material they generate better than material they only read (Slamecka & Graf, 1978).
The same distinction applies to feedback. Feedback that addresses the process a student used, and the student’s regulation of it, supports learning more than feedback that addresses the task alone (Hattie & Timperley, 2007). A guiding question directs attention to that process.
A hint can remove the decision. A guiding question keeps the mathematical decision with the student.
Mixed Practice: Make Choosing the Method Part of the Mathematics
Blocked practice presents one problem type at a time (AAA BBB CCC). Mixed practice, which researchers call interleaving, mixes the problem types within one set (ABC ABC ABC). In blocked practice, the problem's location often tells the student what to do. If every problem on the page is multiplication, choosing multiplication is not part of the task. In mixed practice, the student has to examine the quantities and relationships and decide what mathematics applies. Choosing a method becomes part of the problem.
In one study, college students practiced several types of mathematics problems either in blocked sets or in mixed sets. On a test one week later, students who practiced mixed sets performed far better (Rohrer & Taylor, 2007). Interleaving also improved category learning in a study that used paintings rather than mathematics, even though participants judged blocked study to be more effective (Kornell & Bjork, 2008). Retrieving a method from memory, which mixed practice requires on every problem, also strengthens retention (Roediger & Butler, 2011).
The goal is not simply variety. Students need to discriminate among mathematical structures:
Is this additive or multiplicative?
Is the unknown a part, a total, a factor, or a comparison?
What unit is being counted?
Which representation makes the relationship visible?
Blocked practice can make the method obvious. Mixed practice requires the student to determine which mathematical relationship and method fit the problem.
The Trifecta: The Mathematical Decisions Stay With the Student
Productive struggle asks the student to generate an idea. Restraint with hints keeps the mathematical decision with the student. Mixed practice requires the student to decide which idea or method applies. All three shift some of the mathematical decision-making from the teacher or the assignment back to the student.
The goal is not difficulty. The goal is thinking. Students need opportunities to make sense of quantities and relationships, represent the mathematics, choose a method, explain why it fits, and connect the method back to the problem's structure.
All three practices leave more of the mathematical decisions with the student. The goal is not difficulty. The goal is thinking.
Conclusion: Leave More of the Mathematical Work With the Student
Productive struggle, restraint with hints, and mixed practice have something important in common: they leave more of the mathematical work with the student.
The student has to generate an idea, decide what information matters, choose a representation or method, and determine whether the reasoning makes sense. That may make learning look slower in the moment.
The goal is not to make mathematics harder. The goal is to preserve the thinking that allows students to understand the structure, choose a method, and use what they know when the problem changes.
Learning is not measured only by what students can do immediately after we show them. It is also what they can reconstruct, choose, and use later.
References
Bjork, E. L., & Bjork, R. A. (2011). Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning. In M. A. Gernsbacher, R. W. Pew, L. M. Hough, & J. R. Pomerantz (Eds.), Psychology and the real world: Essays illustrating fundamental contributions to society (pp. 56-64). Worth Publishers.
Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77(1), 81-112. https://doi.org/10.3102/003465430298487
Hiebert, J., & Grouws, D. A. (2007). The effects of classroom mathematics teaching on students’ learning. In F. K. Lester (Ed.), Second handbook of research on mathematics teaching and learning (pp. 371-404). Information Age Publishing.
Kapur, M. (2014). Productive failure in learning math. Cognitive Science, 38(5), 1008-1022. https://doi.org/10.1111/cogs.12107
Kapur, M., & Bielaczyc, K. (2012). Designing for productive failure. Journal of the Learning Sciences, 21(1), 45-83. https://doi.org/10.1080/10508406.2011.591717
Kornell, N., & Bjork, R. A. (2008). Learning concepts and categories: Is spacing the “enemy of induction”? Psychological Science, 19(6), 585-592. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2008.02127.x
Roediger, H. L., & Butler, A. C. (2011). The critical role of retrieval practice in long-term retention. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 15(1), 20-27. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2010.09.003
Rohrer, D., & Taylor, K. (2007). The shuffling of mathematics problems improves learning. Instructional Science, 35(6), 481-498. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11251-007-9015-8
Slamecka, N. J., & Graf, P. (1978). The generation effect: Delineation of a phenomenon. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory, 4(6), 592-604. https://doi.org/10.1037/0278-7393.4.6.592
More in How students learn
Ready to teach this?
Math Success has the classroom materials behind this Insight.
PD video
- Developing Mathematical Thinking Framework
- DMTI Overview: Increasing Students' Math Achievement
The Insights explain the mathematics. Math Success gives you the materials to teach it.
One subscription opens everything, for kindergarten through grade 8. You can start today.
Schools can enroll a whole building for $2,000 a year. See school plans
$21 a month per educator
- All core materials
- All intervention materials
- Diagnostics
- Games
- Prep materials: online video professional development
Keep developing mathematical thinkers.